9 Kislev 5785
[All quotes are attributable to the book The Empty Wagon by Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro.]
"Since nationalist ideology is in the category of idol worship, the ideology of religious nationalism is in the category of idol worship combined [with Judaism] (b'shituf)."
- Rabbi Elchonon Wasserman"... Zionism is heresy. It strives to inform us that nationalism, instead of emunah and Torah, is the foundation . . and religious Zionists (Mizrachim) too, who take religious nationalism as a foundation ... by combining two foundations - as in "religious nationalism" - thereby demonstrate that there is an additional foundation to Jewishness, that even without emunah one can be a Jew, although there is an advantage if one is also religious. This is an uprooting of the basis of Judaism. And in certain ways, [the religious Zionists] are worse than the [secular] Zionists, because they (the religious Zionists) change the words of Hashem and are megaleh panim baTorah shelo k'halachah,* as opposed to the [secular] Zionists, who oppose the Torah but do not change it. And even if [religious Zionists] do good things as well, meaning they still do not uproot from themselves the Torah and emunah and they are half people of the Torah and half Zionists, the Zionism in them is still pure heresy." - Rabbi Boruch Ber
"The Chazon Ish strongly opposed Zionism and Mizrachi ... When he saw a sign advertising the opening of a "Religious Zionist" (Dati Leumi) school in Vilna, he immediately ripped down the poster, tore it to shreds, and explained to his students: 'The very name 'Religious nationalist' expresses a need to add to religion and declares that the nationhood of the Jewish people is something other than their religion. Thus it deviates from our emunah!'"
"... Religious Zionists ... have grafted the alien philosophy of nationalism onto their Judaism, in which a nation-state becomes central to a person's identity and validates the existence of the nation. This belief, to varying extents, is the reason for the centrality of the medinah ....
This is the rule: Zionism is a shmad; religious Zionism is the result of the shmad. Zionism wanted to replace Judaism with nationalism. Their strategy was to confuse and conflate Judaic values with nationalist ones. Religious Zionism is the illegitimate spawn of this confused coupling of religion and nationalism."
"Another example of nationalism polluting the Judaism of the religious Zionists is the Zionist idea of the holiness of their soldiers. Religious Zionists are told not merely to appreciate and be grateful to their soldiers, but that they are imbued with holiness, by virtue of the very fact that they are soldiers for Israel. In Judaism, even when the Jews went to war, the fact that someone was 'in the Jewish army' did not, in and of itself, make him holy. Only Torah and mitzvos can make someone holy. On the contrary - nobody was allowed into the army unless they were holy to begin with, because the soldiers needed holiness to protect them and their colleagues in battle. But the reverse - that the very fact that someone is a soldier makes him holy - is alien to the Jewish religion. But not to the Zionists."
Just a couple of days ago, there was an article about a "Black Hebrew" who died in service to the IDF. As a result, his non-Jewish family was awarded the highest honor the Zionist entity can give - citizenship in the "Jewish" State.
The biggest problem today is that few in our present generation of Torah Jews have any idea how thoroughly indoctrinated and assimilated we have become due to the pervasive Zionist influence. Heresy is viewed as normative Judaism.
We have to do something to turn this untenable situation around.
_________________
How can anyone say the IDF is holy when it is full of messianic missionaries, idolaters and goyim?
ReplyDeleteFrom Breaking Israel news 2019, "In February, the IDF will promote a Christian soldier to the rank of lieutenant-colonel, making him the first soldier of his faith to achieve that rank. This comes as the result of a six-year process intended to help the indigenous Christian community integrate into mainstream Israeli society.
The identity of Maj. I must remain secret since he is slated to enter a high-level/high-risk security position. Maj. I, a Greek-Orthodox Christian and a resident of Nazareth Illit, the Jewish town next to Nazareth, is married and the father of a nine-year-old boy and a five-year-old girl. He describes himself as an Aramean-Israeli Christian. He graduated high-school with honors from the Salvatorian Sisters German Catholic School in Nazareth."
According to an Israeli messianic leader, there are atleast 1000 messianics in the IDF.
https://youtu.be/ysL0h8B7jVU?si=PYpd2AGA2f3quPkd
"The presence of around 100 Evangelical Christian volunteers in the Israeli army, including the children of Juergen Buehler, president of the International Christian Embassy in Jerusalem, highlights a unique and heartening aspect of support for Israel. These volunteers, many of whom were born and raised in Israel, view the nation as their home and are committed to its defense and prosperity. The warmth and acceptance shown by the IDF towards these Christian volunteers underscore the inclusive nature of Israel’s society. It recognizes the contributions of all its defenders, regardless of their religious background, seeing their involvement as a blessing for the nation."
https://www.godreports.com/2023/12/one-hundred-evangelical-christians-serving-in-israels-army/
"Pastor Israel Pochtar of Beit Hallel Congregation in Ashdod says, “The needs are great because the military expenses are very high and it’s affecting the Israeli economy. The prices are growing, the economy is suffering, and we’re going to see consequences more and more because this war is very costly.”
"Despite the challenges, the light of Christ is breaking through. Beit Hallel Congregation actively supports Israeli Christians in the military. Pochtar estimates there are at least 1,000 Christian Israeli soldiers, including 35 from his church. He also has two sons in Israel’s military.
“We’ve never had such a big number of Christians who are in the army, who are sharing their faith and becoming a living letter of Jesus, of God for all people,” says Pochtar. “We have lots and lots of powerful testimonies and saved lives!” https://www.mnnonline.org/news/christian-soldiers-are-a-light-for-christ-in-israels-military/
I think maybe it's not so black and white. We are chassidim, just to self-identify before anyone makes assumptions. What I want to say is that yes, Judaism is a religion, but we are also an Am. The Torah is filled with pesukim where Hashem calls us His Am. Being just a religion is one of the reasons the secular feel they can be not religious. It's like every other religion, right? You can be a practicing Catholic l'havdil, or not. The same with Judaism, right? The goyim also look at us this way, as a religion. And therefore as just a religious group, we have no right to "uproot" an existing population, "steal" their land and create a new state. So I see the issue in a more complex and less black and white way. I agree with the comments about the IDF.
ReplyDelete"It's like every other religion, right?"
DeleteNo, and this is where your logic breaks down. We are not "an" Am, but "the" Am who practice "the" religion - the ONLY religion allowed to mankind - one path for Jews and one path for the nations.
No that was not my logic breaking down. I was writing in the voice of those who see Judaism as only a religion. It was not my question. I don't have any questions. I know who I am.
DeleteI can't seem to make my point strongly enough. Anyone who sees Judaism as "only a religion" knows nothing of Torah Judaism. There is no such idea in the Torah and that is just the point. (No idea where any "question" comes into it.)
DeleteI listen to Yacov Shapiro by chance yesterday in a pro Palestinian YouTube channel. I don’t care his pro o vs sionist idioligy. (I don’t consider my self a sionist, I fit more with the haredim). I think he was speaking Motzi Shem ra of am Israel in the open world, and to my eyes he is in the category of a moser. There are also haredim that are erev rab.
ReplyDeleteGavriela, there was a great Rabbi from a number of decades ago. His name wass Rabbi Zimmerman, ztl, (I think Chaim Z) and he was so upset at the rabbis who used the terminology for true Torah Yiddishkeit by the word description 'religion'. He said there is no such word as religion in the Torah; everything outside of Torah is idolatry. So when we use the words Jewish religion, we are then equatingTorah to avodah zorahs, c'v. He called Torah Yiddishkeit, the Eternal Truth and not use the word 'religion'.
ReplyDeleteThis is why I think H' made us, His people, Yisrael, all from one family; therefore, making us unique, inasmuch as we are all Jewish neshamot.
That differentiates us from all the other nations. It is not our external
bodies but our unique Yiddishe neshamot. So even righteous converts
are of the same neshamah as the rest of our Am
Tzion
So I guess readers think I was asking these questions. It's my editorial error. I should have put the questions in quotes, but was lazy. I was sharing the position of those who are secular who see Judaism only as a religion. For instance my therapist once said, "my family is Jewish but I don't practice Judaism." The goyim also see it this way and therefore deny our right to our inheritance because a religious group is not entitled to a Land. Hope this clears up the matter for everyone. As I already wrote, I have no questions on this subject. I know whonI am.
DeleteUnderstood, Gaviela. Of course, we who truly believe understand what you are saying but I never gave thought to what you wrote here about the nations calling us a religion, 'so why do we need a land of our own'. They really think they have everything covered.
DeleteTzion
Gavriela, I understood that you were asking others' questions, not your own. Those who have read your blog and commentary over a period of years are more likely to understand what you meant above.
ReplyDelete