tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2492192659601155685.post1858016020154121874..comments2024-03-29T07:15:48.612+03:00Comments on TOMER DEVORAH: Parshat Shoftim 5774Devorah Chayahhttp://www.blogger.com/profile/03625277197970920616noreply@blogger.comBlogger4125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2492192659601155685.post-65009745956915541852014-09-02T02:21:19.588+03:002014-09-02T02:21:19.588+03:00Jesterhead45: Don't think your question will h...Jesterhead45: Don't think your question will have any relevance when Moshiach comes. This is all from Hashem and we need not worry anymore after that. This will be the end of history and Moshiach will rule forever. Every question and problem will be answered and solved. Eventually, the supernatural will become natural.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2492192659601155685.post-37548575374902091662014-08-31T06:12:01.882+03:002014-08-31T06:12:01.882+03:00Anonymous - 29/8/14 4:00 PM
While aware of the hi...Anonymous - 29/8/14 4:00 PM<br /><br />While aware of the history, my question is more theoretical then historical. <br /><br />In the case of the Chasmanoim or another tribe assuming kingship with the consent of a prophet as mentioned in the article above, what would happen in a scenario where a descendant of the Davidic dynasty appears and demands the ruling dynasty from another tribe to step down? <br /><br />While the requirement of the Davidic dynasty is to descend from King David via King Solomon, does that mean in practice that King David's descendants from his other sons are effectively reduced to the tribal status of Yehuda?<br /><br />Thanks for answering. Jesterhead45https://www.blogger.com/profile/06569998708665000668noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2492192659601155685.post-19103034519450730472014-08-29T16:00:14.784+03:002014-08-29T16:00:14.784+03:00The Davidic dynasty has to descend from King David...The Davidic dynasty has to descend from King David, thru his son, Solomon. Only descendants of David Hamelech through Solomon are allowed on the Throne of Israel. The Chasmanoim were wiped out eventually because of their arrogance of taking over the throne. Their role was the Priesthood. Power does lead to arrogance. The same holds true with the Tribe of Ephraim who usurped the throne from the Davidic Dynasty; thus they (10 lost tribes) are lost up until this day. Moshiach 'Tzdkeinu' will be anointed by Hashem.Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2492192659601155685.post-90944643400507568152014-08-29T09:05:52.397+03:002014-08-29T09:05:52.397+03:00Some questions pop into mind regarding the scenari...Some questions pop into mind regarding the scenario of a prophet appointing a king from another tribe other then Yehuda (or even a king from potentially non-Davidic branches of Yehuda).<br /><br />When it comes to Jewish monarchy in the Eretz Yisrael, what would typically be the procedure in a hypothetical scenario where a descendant of David appears during the reign of a non-Yehuda ruled monarchy like for example the Hasmonean dynasty? <br /><br />While it would be expected for a non-Davidic / non-Yehuda dynasty to step aside in such a scenario, is it based simply on lineage alone that the non-Davidic dynasty is required to give way or is it lineage plus how G-d Fearing (and competent) the descendant of David is in order to prevent another Manasseh from ascending the throne? <br /><br />Also, are descendants of David via David's other progeny classed as Yehuda or Davidic (albeit non-Solomon)? <br />Jesterhead45https://www.blogger.com/profile/06569998708665000668noreply@blogger.com